NA 3 · Neighbor Advocate~9 min
Three Minutes at the Hearing: Speaking to the Record
A public participation hearing on a large project is not a school board meeting. A judge presides, a court reporter records what you say, the applicant's team may be in the room, and the people who decide may not be. NA3 adapts the three-minute structure from PA2 to a hearing that is transcribed: speaking so your words read well on paper, coordinating a room of speakers so each adds a different fact, the scoping meeting as the earlier and often more useful version, and holding steady when the room is loud.
Three Minutes at the Hearing: Speaking to the Record
The hall is full. Three hundred people, a sign-up table at the door, a microphone at the front, and at a table facing the room, a judge and a court reporter typing everything. Some of the people who will vote on the project may not be there. In a few months, someone writing the proposed decision will read what was said tonight, and they will read it as words on a page, without the applause, without the faces, without the sense of the room.
That changes how you should speak. PA2 taught three minutes at a school board, where the people who vote are sitting in front of you. This is three minutes for a reader who is not in the room yet.
What the hearing is
At the CPUC, a public participation hearing (the Commission also calls these Public Forums) is where it takes public comment in person. In the Commission's words, they "are led by a CPUC Administrative Law Judge, and CPUC Commissioners may also attend," and "there will be a CPUC court reporter present to record your comments for the record." The Commission adds that "public comments are taken into consideration by the Commissioners and Administrative Law Judge in their decision-making" (CPUC).
Three things follow. You are speaking to the judge and to the record, not to the applicant, whose staff may be present but are not the audience. What lasts is the transcript, so the transcript is what you are writing for. And like a written comment, its power is in what it tells the decision-makers that they did not already know.
Speak for the page
A court reporter is fast and careful, but a transcript flattens everything that is not words. Speak so the page holds your point on its own.
- Say names and places in full, once. "The creek crossing on [road name], two miles east of Highway 79," not "our road." Spell an unusual name: "Aguanga, A-G-U-A-N-G-A."
- Give numbers with their units and their source. "Two point one miles from the proposed centerline, by the county parcel map," not "really close."
- Do not point. "This map here" becomes "this map here" in the transcript, with no map.
- Do not rely on the room. Applause does not travel. A sentence that only lands because the crowd cheered will read as half a sentence.
- End sentences. Nerves make speakers trail off. A finished sentence is a quotable one.
The structure, adapted
PA2's four parts still work. The budget shifts toward the fact, because the fact is the only part nobody else in the room can supply.
1. Locate (about 20 seconds). Your name, your town, and where you are in relation to the project. "My name is [____]. I have lived on [road] in [town] for twenty-two years, about two miles from the proposed route."
2. The fact (about 90 seconds). One thing you know firsthand, said precisely, with how you know it. This is NA2's inventory, spoken. "That road is the only paved way out for forty-one households. It floods at the creek crossing most Februaries. In 2023 it was closed for nine days; I have the county's closure notices."
3. The ask (about 30 seconds). Something the decision-maker or the environmental report can actually do. "I am asking that the environmental report study evacuation on [road] during a winter closure, and that the Commission require that analysis before it decides." The incremental ask (F8) lives here: the smallest move that matters, inside what this body can do.
4. The record line (about 20 seconds). One sentence that would still make sense if it were the only line of yours anyone read. "Forty-one households, one road, and nine days in 2023 when it was under water: that should be in the record before this line is approved."
That leaves twenty seconds for breath, a slow start and the microphone. The figures in these examples are invented. The precision is not optional.
Then post the longer version in writing (NA2) and say at the microphone that you have.
The room as a team
A full hall is a resource, and an uncoordinated one wastes itself. Twenty speakers who each say "this line will ruin our community" give the record one point twenty times. Twenty speakers who each bring a different fact give it twenty.
If you are organizing, build the speaker list by topic before the night: the evacuation road, the well records, the ranch, the business, the nesting site, the fire history, the cost to ratepayers. Each speaker owns one. Put the most precise speakers early, when attention is freshest. Agree in advance that nobody repeats a fact already given, and that anyone who finds their point has been made will say "I agree with the speaker on evacuation, and I add one thing" and then add it.
Ask the public advisor ahead of time how sign-up works, whether there is a time limit, and whether interpretation will be available if people in your community need it. Those are procedural questions, and answering them is that office's job.
The earlier microphone: scoping
The public participation hearing is the visible one. The more useful microphone often comes years earlier, at the environmental review's scoping meeting, when the agency is still deciding what its report should study. For projects of statewide, regional or areawide significance, the lead agency "shall conduct at least one scoping meeting" (CEQA Guidelines §15082), and the Guidelines describe scoping as a way to bring together the concerns of agencies, the applicant "and other interested persons including those who might not be in accord with the action on environmental grounds" (§15083).
At scoping, the ask is simple and powerful: study this. The evacuation road, the spring, the alternative route through an existing corridor. An impact the report studies is one the decision has to reckon with. An impact it never studies is much harder to raise later.
Holding steady
Large hearings can be loud, and some speakers will be angry. Some will disagree with you, including neighbors. The discipline is the same as in F9: you came to put one fact into the record, and nothing that happens in the room changes the fact.
- Look at the judge, not the crowd.
- Keep the card in your hand: your opening line, your fact, your ask.
- If you lose your place, say the fact. It is the one part you know by heart because it happened to you.
- Do not answer another speaker. The hearing is not a debate, and the transcript does not need the argument.
If you have done the Trailhead preparation room, the Belayer can run the night-before rehearsal with you: your own opening line, your own fact, your own recovery line. It holds the rope. You still do the climb.
Skill, not side
A resident who wants the project built speaks at the same microphone, on the same terms, and is heard the same way: one precise fact and one ask beat three minutes of conviction. Everything here applies to them unchanged.
Bringing the Foundations toolkit here
Reading the room (Field 2.3) tells you who in a hearing hall actually matters. The story map (F5) turns your fact into ninety seconds a listener can follow. Emotional fortitude (F9) keeps your voice steady. Showing up (F10) is why the public advisor already knows your group by the night of the hearing.
What comes next
One person with one fact can change a document. A proceeding that runs for years is changed by people who hold together. NA4 is about the coalition: how neighbors who are all affected, but not equally and not in the same place, keep from turning on each other.
Exercise
Build your three minutes around the one fact from your NA2 inventory that matters most. Write: (1) the locate sentence, including the name of your town or road and how far you are from the project; (2) the fact, with the place, the date and how you know it, said the way you would say it aloud; (3) the ask, as something the decision-maker or the environmental report can actually do; (4) one closing sentence that would still make sense if it were the only line of yours in the transcript. Read it aloud against a timer and cut until it lands under 2:45 with breath. Then note the names or numbers in it that a court reporter might mishear, and how you will say or spell them.
Sign in to write and save your response here — the Library stays free either way.
Downloadables
- The Hearing Card
A one-page field card for speaking at a public participation hearing or a scoping meeting: the four-part structure adapted for a transcript, the speak-for-the-page checklist, how to coordinate speakers by topic, and the minutes before you are called.
Frequently asked questions
- Who am I actually talking to at a public participation hearing?
- To the record, and to the judge who presides. The CPUC says its public participation hearings are led by an Administrative Law Judge, that Commissioners may also attend, and that a court reporter is present to record your comments for the record. Speak to the front of the room, not to the applicant's staff or the crowd.
- Should I still send a written comment if I speak?
- Yes. Three minutes holds one fact and one ask. Post the fuller version on the proceeding's docket card through the Public Comment tab, or send it to the environmental review if it is about an environmental effect. Say at the microphone that you have done so.
- What if the room is hostile, or I lose my place?
- Look at the judge, find your fact, and say it. A sentence that is calm and specific reads better in a transcript than a minute that is loud. The Belayer can rehearse it with you the night before, and F9 (emotional fortitude) is the longer training.